From 3793e9cc8a2e56ebe479b7fa4757c72cb857411b Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Jared Pleva Date: Mon, 30 Mar 2026 00:49:56 +0000 Subject: [PATCH] =?UTF-8?q?chore(squad):=20EM=20state=20update=20=E2=80=94?= =?UTF-8?q?=20run=206=20(2026-03-30)?= MIME-Version: 1.0 Content-Type: text/plain; charset=UTF-8 Content-Transfer-Encoding: 8bit - P0 COMPLETE: PRs #83/#84/#85 merged, all P0 governance bugs closed - Issue #59 closed (already fixed by PR #83) - PR #86 opened: fix P1 #28 — governance timeout override (60s cap removed) - PR budget: 1/3 (was 3/3 at-limit) - Dogfood (#76) unblocked from governance side — needs human trigger - P1 remaining: #28 (in PR #86), #63/#68 (qa-agent) Co-Authored-By: Claude Sonnet 4.6 --- .agentguard/squads/shellforge/blockers.md | 73 +++++++++++----------- .agentguard/squads/shellforge/state.json | 74 ++++++++++------------- 2 files changed, 65 insertions(+), 82 deletions(-) diff --git a/.agentguard/squads/shellforge/blockers.md b/.agentguard/squads/shellforge/blockers.md index fccbdf2..225b4b1 100644 --- a/.agentguard/squads/shellforge/blockers.md +++ b/.agentguard/squads/shellforge/blockers.md @@ -1,64 +1,61 @@ # ShellForge Squad — Blockers -**Updated:** 2026-03-29T20:00Z -**Reported by:** EM run 5 (claude-code:opus:shellforge:em) +**Updated:** 2026-03-30T00:45Z +**Reported by:** EM run 6 (claude-code:opus:shellforge:em) --- -## P0 — Critical Blockers (2) +## P0 — Critical Blockers -### 1. All 3 PRs Awaiting Human Review — BLOCKING SQUAD PROGRESS -**Description:** All 3 open PRs are passing CI (5/5 checks each) but blocked on `REVIEW_REQUIRED`. GitHub branch protection prevents the EM (authored as jpleva91) from self-approving. -**PRs blocked:** -- **#83** — `fix(p0): close governance fail-open vulnerabilities` — closes #58, #59, #62, #67, #69, #75 -- **#84** — `fix(docs): update stale Crush comments in cmdEvaluate (#74)` — closes #74 -- **#85** — `chore(squad): EM state update — run 4` — squad ops housekeeping - -**Action Required:** @jpleva91 or a collaborator must review and approve PRs #83, #84, #85. -**Priority:** Review #83 first — it carries all P0/P1 governance security fixes. - -### 2. PR Budget AT LIMIT (3/3) — No New Fix PRs Possible -**Description:** Squad has reached the max of 3 open PRs. No new work can be opened until at least one PR merges. -**Impact:** P2 bugs (#65 scheduler silent error, #66 flattenParams dead code, #52 cmdScan glob broken, #53 README stale) remain queued but cannot be addressed. -**Unblocked by:** Merging any of #83, #84, or #85. +**None.** All P0 governance bugs are closed. --- -## P1 — Remaining Work (queued, no new PRs until budget frees) +## P1 — Active Work -### #68 — Zero test coverage across all packages -**Severity:** High — governance runtime with no tests is unshipable -**Impact:** Can't validate fix correctness, no regression protection. Blocks dogfood credibility. -**Assignee:** qa-agent -**URL:** https://github.com/AgentGuardHQ/shellforge/issues/68 +### PR #86 — Governance timeout override (awaiting human review) +**Description:** PR #86 removes the hardcoded 60s cap in `runShellWithRTK` and `runShellRaw` that silently overrode the governance engine's timeout value. CI pending; GitHub branch protection prevents self-approval. +**Action Required:** @jpleva91 review and approve PR #86. ### #63 — classifyShellRisk prefix matching too broad **Severity:** High — false read-only classification on commands starting with `cat`/`ls`/`echo` **Assignee:** qa-agent **URL:** https://github.com/AgentGuardHQ/shellforge/issues/63 +### #68 — Zero test coverage across all packages +**Severity:** High — governance runtime with no tests is unshipable +**Assignee:** qa-agent +**URL:** https://github.com/AgentGuardHQ/shellforge/issues/68 + --- -## P2 — Unassigned (queued, blocked by PR budget) +## P2 — Queued (unassigned) | # | Issue | Notes | |---|-------|-------| +| #76 | Dogfood: run ShellForge swarm on jared box | P0 governance bugs resolved — can now proceed | | #65 | scheduler.go silent os.WriteFile error | Silent failure on job persistence | | #66 | flattenParams dead code | Logic bug, result overwritten before use | -| #52 | filepath.Glob ** never matches Go files | cmdScan broken for entire scan feature | +| #52 | filepath.Glob ** never matches Go files | cmdScan scan feature broken | | #53 | README stale ./shellforge commands | Docs rot | +| #51 | run() helper silently ignores errors | Silent failure in main.go | +| #50 | kernel version comparison lexicographic | setup.sh version gate broken | +| #49 | InferenceQueue not priority-aware | Documented but unimplemented | +| #26 | run-qa/report agents don't build binary if missing | Setup gap | +| #25 | RunResult.Success heuristic incorrect | Agent loop reliability | +| #24 | listFiles() relative paths bug | Path resolution error | --- -## Resolved (pending merge of PR #83) +## Resolved (this cycle) -- **#58** — bounded-execution wildcard policy blocked all run_shell → fix in PR #83 -- **#62** — cmdEvaluate fail-open on JSON unmarshal → fix in PR #83 -- **#75** — govern-shell.sh printf injection → fix in PR #83 -- **#67** — govern-shell.sh fragile sed output parsing → fix in PR #83 -- **#69** — rm policy only blocked -rf/-fr, not plain rm → fix in PR #83 -- **#59** — misleading `# Mode: monitor` comment with `mode: enforce` → fix in PR #83 -- **#74** — stale crush references in cmdEvaluate → fix in PR #84 +- **#58** — bounded-execution wildcard policy blocked all run_shell → merged in PR #83 +- **#62** — cmdEvaluate fail-open on JSON unmarshal → merged in PR #83 +- **#75** — govern-shell.sh printf injection → merged in PR #83 +- **#67** — govern-shell.sh fragile sed output parsing → merged in PR #83 +- **#69** — rm policy only blocked -rf/-fr, not plain rm → merged in PR #83 +- **#74** — stale crush references in cmdEvaluate → merged in PR #84 +- **#59** — misleading `# Mode: monitor` comment → fixed in PR #83, closed manually --- @@ -66,12 +63,10 @@ | Item | Status | |------|--------| -| PR #83 (P0 fixes) | CI ✅ 5/5 — REVIEW BLOCKED | -| PR #84 (P1 docs) | CI ✅ 5/5 — REVIEW BLOCKED | -| PR #85 (EM state) | CI ✅ 5/5 — REVIEW BLOCKED | -| PR budget | 3/3 AT LIMIT | -| Dogfood (#76) | BLOCKED on #83 merge | +| P0 issues | ✅ All closed | +| PR #86 (P1 timeout fix) | CI pending — REVIEW REQUIRED | +| PR budget | 1/3 | +| Dogfood (#76) | Governance unblocked — needs human trigger | | QA-agent (#63, #68) | Active | -| New fix PRs | BLOCKED until budget frees | | Retry loops | None | | Blast radius | Low | diff --git a/.agentguard/squads/shellforge/state.json b/.agentguard/squads/shellforge/state.json index 2748f29..cced989 100644 --- a/.agentguard/squads/shellforge/state.json +++ b/.agentguard/squads/shellforge/state.json @@ -1,77 +1,67 @@ { "squad": "shellforge", - "updated_at": "2026-03-29T20:00:00Z", + "updated_at": "2026-03-30T00:45:00Z", "sprint": { "goal": "Harden enforcement runtime — fix all P0/P1 governance bugs before dogfood run", - "focus": "Security correctness: govern-shell.sh JSON safety, cmdEvaluate bypass, bounded-execution policy, test coverage baseline" + "focus": "Security correctness: P0 COMPLETE, P1 #28 in PR #86, test coverage (#68) and classifyShellRisk (#63) assigned to qa-agent" }, "pr_budget": { "max_open": 3, - "current_open": 3, - "status": "at-limit" + "current_open": 1, + "status": "ok" }, "loop_guard": { "retry_loop_detected": false, "blast_radius": "low" }, "issue_queue": { - "p0": [ - { "number": 58, "title": "Critical: bounded-execution policy denies ALL run_shell calls in enforce mode", "assignee": "em", "status": "fix-in-pr-83" }, - { "number": 62, "title": "bug: cmdEvaluate silently ignores JSON unmarshal error — governance bypass", "assignee": "em", "status": "fix-in-pr-83" }, - { "number": 75, "title": "bug: govern-shell.sh unescaped $COMMAND in printf — silently defaults to allow", "assignee": "em", "status": "fix-in-pr-83" } - ], + "p0": [], "p1": [ - { "number": 69, "title": "bug: governance policy gap — plain rm and rm -r not blocked by no-destructive-rm", "assignee": "em", "status": "fix-in-pr-83" }, - { "number": 67, "title": "bug: govern-shell.sh uses fragile sed to parse JSON", "assignee": "em", "status": "fix-in-pr-83" }, + { "number": 28, "title": "bug: bounded-execution policy timeout (300s) is silently overridden to 60s in shell execution", "assignee": "em", "status": "fix-in-pr-86" }, { "number": 63, "title": "bug: classifyShellRisk prefix matching too broad — false read-only classification", "assignee": "qa-agent" }, - { "number": 68, "title": "test: zero test coverage across all packages", "assignee": "qa-agent" }, - { "number": 74, "title": "bug: stale crush references in cmd/shellforge/main.go", "assignee": "em", "status": "fix-in-pr-84" } + { "number": 68, "title": "test: zero test coverage across all packages", "assignee": "qa-agent" } ], "p2": [ { "number": 65, "title": "bug: scheduler.go silently ignores os.WriteFile error", "assignee": null }, { "number": 66, "title": "bug: dead code in flattenParams() overwrites result before using it", "assignee": null }, { "number": 52, "title": "bug: filepath.Glob with ** in cmdScan never matches any Go files", "assignee": null }, - { "number": 59, "title": "agentguard.yaml misleading comment says monitor but mode is enforce", "assignee": "em", "status": "fix-in-pr-83" }, { "number": 53, "title": "docs/readme: README still shows ./shellforge commands", "assignee": null }, - { "number": 76, "title": "Dogfood: run ShellForge swarm on jared box via RunPod GPU", "assignee": null } + { "number": 76, "title": "Dogfood: run ShellForge swarm on jared box via RunPod GPU", "assignee": null }, + { "number": 51, "title": "bug: run() helper in main.go silently ignores command errors", "assignee": null }, + { "number": 50, "title": "bug: kernel version comparison in setup.sh is lexicographic, not numeric", "assignee": null }, + { "number": 49, "title": "bug: InferenceQueue is not priority-aware despite being documented as such", "assignee": null }, + { "number": 26, "title": "bug: run-qa-agent.sh and run-report-agent.sh don't build binary if missing", "assignee": null }, + { "number": 25, "title": "bug: agent RunResult.Success heuristic is incorrect", "assignee": null }, + { "number": 24, "title": "bug: listFiles() returns paths relative to cwd, not the listed directory", "assignee": null } ], "p3": [ + { "number": 81, "title": "feat: OpenClaw as governed execution runtime in ShellForge", "assignee": null }, { "number": 77, "title": "[research] Evaluate go-agent-framework sandboxing integration", "assignee": null }, - { "number": 71, "title": "[research] lean-ctx — 88% token reduction via shell hook + MCP server", "assignee": null }, { "number": 73, "title": "[research] ml-explore/mlx-lm — Apple MLX inference backend", "assignee": null }, { "number": 72, "title": "[research] nono — kernel-enforced agent sandbox via macOS Seatbelt", "assignee": null }, + { "number": 71, "title": "[research] lean-ctx — 88% token reduction via shell hook + MCP server", "assignee": null }, { "number": 56, "title": "[research] mem0 — persistent cross-run agent memory", "assignee": null }, { "number": 55, "title": "[research] microsoft/agent-governance-toolkit", "assignee": null }, { "number": 54, "title": "[research] omlx — SSD KV caching doubles swarm capacity", "assignee": null }, - { "number": 81, "title": "feat: OpenClaw as governed execution runtime in ShellForge", "assignee": null } + { "number": 11, "title": "[research] RTK integration — 70-90% token savings for agent runs", "assignee": null }, + { "number": 10, "title": "[research] TurboQuant integration — 6x KV cache compression", "assignee": null } ] }, "pr_queue": [ { - "number": 83, - "title": "fix(p0): close governance fail-open vulnerabilities", - "status": "open", - "ci": "passing (5/5)", - "review_status": "REVIEW_REQUIRED — awaiting human approval (cannot self-approve)", - "issues_closed": [58, 59, 62, 67, 69, 75] - }, - { - "number": 84, - "title": "fix(docs): update stale Crush comments in cmdEvaluate (#74)", - "status": "open", - "ci": "passing (5/5)", - "review_status": "REVIEW_REQUIRED — awaiting human approval (cannot self-approve)", - "issues_closed": [74] - }, - { - "number": 85, - "title": "chore(squad): EM state update — run 4 (2026-03-29)", + "number": 86, + "title": "fix(governance): honour policy timeout in shell execution — remove 60s cap (#28)", "status": "open", - "ci": "passing (5/5)", - "review_status": "REVIEW_REQUIRED — awaiting human approval (cannot self-approve)", - "issues_closed": [] + "ci": "pending", + "review_status": "REVIEW_REQUIRED — awaiting human approval", + "issues_closed": [28] } ], + "recently_closed": [ + { "number": 83, "merged": true, "issues_closed": [58, 62, 67, 69, 75], "date": "2026-03-30" }, + { "number": 84, "merged": true, "issues_closed": [74], "date": "2026-03-30" }, + { "number": 85, "merged": true, "issues_closed": [], "date": "2026-03-30" } + ], "agents": { "qa-agent": { "status": "assigned", "schedule": "4h", "last_issue": 63 }, "report-agent": { "status": "idle", "schedule": "30m", "last_issue": null }, @@ -82,10 +72,8 @@ "No dev-agent in swarm — P0/P1 bugs require EM to author fixes directly" ], "blockers": [ - "PR #83 (P0 fixes): CI passing 5/5, review BLOCKED — GitHub prevents self-approval. Requires human review from @jpleva91 or a collaborator.", - "PR #84 (P1 docs fix): CI passing 5/5, review BLOCKED — same constraint.", - "PR #85 (EM state update): CI passing 5/5, review BLOCKED — same constraint.", - "PR budget AT LIMIT (3/3) — cannot open new fix PRs until at least one merges." + "PR #86 (P1 timeout fix): CI pending, review BLOCKED — GitHub prevents self-approval. Requires human review from @jpleva91.", + "Dogfood (#76): unblocked by P0 merge but no assignee yet — needs human trigger." ], - "notes": "Run 5 (2026-03-29T20:00Z): No new issues since Run 4. All 3 open PRs now passing CI (5/5) but all blocked on REVIEW_REQUIRED — GitHub branch protection prevents self-approval. PR budget at limit (3/3). No new work can be opened. Dogfood run (#76) still blocked pending PR #83 merge. Human review of PRs #83, #84, #85 is the sole critical path item." + "notes": "Run 6 (2026-03-30T00:45Z): PRs #83/#84/#85 all merged — P0 COMPLETE. Issue #59 closed (was already fixed by #83). PR #86 opened for last P1 (#28, timeout override). PR budget 1/3. Sprint goal nearly achieved — remaining P1s are #28 (in PR), #63/#68 (qa-agent). Dogfood run (#76) is unblocked from governance side but needs human to trigger." }