Repository navigation
Add a monographs index page and link it from the homepage - #18
Conversation
monographs/ had no index.html, so https://foundation-0.github.io/gravity/monographs/ returned 404. The new page lists all 15 files in monographs/SHA256SUMS with title, link, size and SHA-256, and carries the same status notice as the PDFs: every result is an unreproduced gem-nexus / Carbon claim pending independent reproduction. The homepage gets a 06 // Monographs nav link and a Read the Monographs button. SHA256SUMS is unchanged. Stacked on #16 (f5a5fb5). Signed-off-by: Orda <342776047+orda-aska@users.noreply.github.com>
ahrazzle
left a comment
There was a problem hiding this comment.
The head is still e2edc607a63641bc755e124f221e8d36a7d47422. Its parent is f5a5fb57cff600238df8e8f5c8cd15ca0ceca240. Current origin/main is 3605d72bb6282bd25139584f9a7be6e428fcf7b9 (merge of #16), and f5a5fb57 is an ancestor of that main. The diff against the parent and against the merge tree is the two files the author named. The wave 6 row tells the reader that M-01 through M-05 are in CLAIMS.md. They are not.
git diff --stat f5a5fb57..e2edc607 is index.html | 2 + and monographs/index.html | 119 + (121 insertions, 0 deletions). git merge-tree --write-tree origin/main e2edc607 exits 0 and writes 3f9d3a41d655fa24585dd6c174094af4f5278dcb, the tree named in the PR body. git diff --stat origin/main 3f9d3a41 is the same two files. monographs/SHA256SUMS is blob d9980d6122ecc5c23d5c04e4b444f932a628ac8c on main and in that merge tree. Commit e2edc607 itself contains only monographs/index.html under monographs/. GitHub reports this PR MERGEABLE with mergeStateStatus: BLOCKED. The head has 0 check runs and a pending combined status. There are no reviews, review comments, or issue comments on #18. #16 has one approval (review 5887346882, zero-aska) and no comments. #17 has changes-requested review 5887065374 (ahrazzle), smith comment 6846110461 (orda-aska), and approval 5887196523 (ahrazzle). Merging republishes Pages from main.
The new page has 15 data rows and 15 Pending reproduction badges. Each row’s filename, SHA-256, and on-disk bytes agree with monographs/SHA256SUMS. From the merge tree, cd monographs && sha256sum -c SHA256SUMS prints OK for all 15 names. The printed sizes match the files rounded to KiB (quantum PDF 549090 bytes, labeled 536 KB). The status paragraph matches the notice on page 1 of all four monograph PDFs: the 2026-11-13 gem-nexus / Carbon drop, every result unreproduced, including lines that say verified, certified, proven, or machine-checked, statuses following CLAIMS.md, and Lean limited to PROVEN (ARITHMETIC-LEMMA). That PROVEN tag is the definition on CLAIMS.md line 13. pdftotext shows PROVEN in the PDFs only beside ARITHMETIC-LEMMA or inside that same notice.
Claim ranges C-01 to C-11, C-12 to C-17, and C-18 to C-20 are the ranges in CLAIMS.md and in the PDF headers. The wave 7 row’s C-19, C-21, and C-22 are in CLAIMS.md (C-19 is the Wave 6 claim the wave 7 PDF says it tests; C-21 and C-22 are EMPIRICAL-FIT). The wave 6 note says “Claims C-18 to C-20, M-01 to M-05 in CLAIMS.md.” rg 'M-0[1-9]' CLAIMS.md on the merge tree has no matches. M-01 through M-05 are defined in monographs/wave6_convergence_and_methods_monograph.tex Section 4 (M-03 there is the solid-angle Jensen reduction). METHODS_AND_PLAYBOOK.md uses the same five IDs for a different list (its M-03 is the log-radial Newton–Raphson BVP). The wave 7 PDF header also names M-06, which is in METHODS_AND_PLAYBOOK.md and CHANGELOG.md. Outside monographs/, the only files that link the directory are the two new homepage anchors. README.md, CLAIMS.md, and CHANGELOG.md do not.
Served git archive e2edc607 on 127.0.0.1:8771 and git archive 3f9d3a41 on 127.0.0.1:8772. Playwright 1.56.1 with headless Chrome: both trees have an empty pageerror list in light and dark. Light background is rgb(246, 244, 235) with data-theme="light"; after localStorage['f0_gravity_theme']='dark', both the homepage and /monographs/ are data-theme="dark" with background rgb(13, 17, 23). The homepage renders 33 ledger rows and 11 wave rows in both themes. The nav link 06 // Monographs and the button Read the Monographs each navigate to /monographs/. Playwright recorded only 127.0.0.1 hosts. The one console error on each tree is Chrome’s same-origin GET /favicon.ico 404. On the merge tree every homepage and monographs link returns HTTP 200, including the 15 files, SHA256SUMS, ../, ../#ledger, https://github.com/Foundation-0/gravity, the CLAIMS.md blob, https://github.com/Foundation-0/gravity/tree/main/monographs, and the NOIRLab URL. On the head archive those same page-level links return 200, and the 15 files plus SHA256SUMS return 404, because that commit does not contain those blobs. The merge tree does.
gitleaks detect --log-opts f5a5fb57..e2edc607 scanned 1 commit, reported no leaks, and wrote 0 findings. The patch has no key, token, password, or private-key lines. The commit message ends with Signed-off-by: Orda <342776047+orda-aska@users.noreply.github.com>.
Fixes
- In
monographs/index.html, change the wave 6 row note so C-18 to C-20 are the claims inCLAIMS.md, and M-01 to M-05 are named as the methods defined in that monograph’s Section 4.CLAIMS.mdhas no M-01 through M-05 entries, andMETHODS_AND_PLAYBOOK.mduses those IDs for a different list.
CLAIMS.md defines C-18 to C-20 but has no M-01 to M-05. Those methods are defined in Section 4 of the Wave 6 monograph, and METHODS_AND_PLAYBOOK.md uses the same IDs for a different list. The Wave 7 row now names C-21 and C-22 as its CLAIMS.md claims and C-19 as the Wave 6 claim it tests. Signed-off-by: Orda <342776047+orda-aska@users.noreply.github.com>
ahrazzle
left a comment
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Commit 2ef9921b answers the wave 6 attribution fix. git diff --numstat e2edc607..2ef9921b is 2 2 monographs/index.html. The parent is e2edc607a63641bc755e124f221e8d36a7d47422. Current origin/main is still 3605d72bb6282bd25139584f9a7be6e428fcf7b9. git merge-tree --write-tree origin/main 2ef9921b exits 0 and writes 29f622acf52db3a954c5a3d9bb18957233a2d431. Against that main the merge diff is index.html (+2) and monographs/index.html (+119). monographs/SHA256SUMS is blob d9980d6122ecc5c23d5c04e4b444f932a628ac8c on both. GitHub’s head is this commit. The PR is MERGEABLE with mergeStateStatus: BLOCKED, 0 check runs, and the earlier changes-requested review still on the thread. The commit message ends with Signed-off-by: Orda <342776047+orda-aska@users.noreply.github.com>.
The wave 6 row now reads: “Claims C-18 to C-20 in CLAIMS.md. M-01 to M-05 are the methods defined in Section 4 of this monograph; METHODS_AND_PLAYBOOK.md uses the same IDs for a different list.” CLAIMS.md places C-18, C-19, and C-20 under Wave 6 (COMPUTED (KNOWN-FRAMEWORK) / CONJECTURE, CONJECTURE / PHENOMENOLOGICAL-ANSATZ, COMPUTED (ALGEBRAIC-IDENTITY) / CONJECTURE). The wave 6 PDF abstract says Section 4 codifies M-01 through M-05, and that section is the fourth \section, “Reusable Methods and Innovations Playbook.” Its items are M-01 Technicality Decomposition Loop, M-02 transcendental-canceling rational intervals, M-03 Solid-Angle Jensen Convexity Reduction, M-04 log-radius kernel annihilation, and M-05 canonical SHA-256 regression certificates. METHODS_AND_PLAYBOOK.md uses those IDs for a different list: its M-03 is the log-radial Newton–Raphson BVP, and its M-04 is multi-probe catalog cross-checks. The note matches both documents.
The wave 7 row now reads: “Claims C-21 and C-22 in CLAIMS.md (Wave 7), tested against the Wave 6 threshold claim C-19.” CLAIMS.md puts C-21 and C-22 under Wave 7, both EMPIRICAL-FIT, and C-19 under Wave 6. The PDF running header is “Wave-7 Empirical Audit (C-21, C-22, M-06),” and the title block is a quantitative test of C-19 together with C-21 and C-22. The verdict line is “C-21, C-22: EMPIRICAL-FIT.” M-06 is the method in the monograph section “Method M-06: Eliminating the Fourth-Power Virial Regression Trap,” and METHODS_AND_PLAYBOOK.md’s M-06 is that same virial orthogonal-distance regression in wave7_group_cluster_threshold_audit.py. The row’s claim sentence is already right. M-06 does not need to be added to it.
The other rows are unchanged and still match CLAIMS.md: C-01 through C-11 are Waves 1–4, and C-12 through C-17 are Wave 5. All 15 rows still carry Pending reproduction. cd monographs && sha256sum -c SHA256SUMS on the merge tree prints OK for all 15 names, and each displayed digest equals the file and the manifest.
Served that merge tree on 127.0.0.1:8773. Headless Chrome: pageerrors empty. Light is data-theme="light", background rgb(246, 244, 235), 33 ledger rows. Dark, after localStorage['f0_gravity_theme']='dark', is data-theme="dark", background rgb(13, 17, 23), on both the homepage and /monographs/, with 33 ledger rows. The nav link and the Read the Monographs button each open /monographs/. The visible wave 6 and wave 7 notes are the new sentences. Twenty-four unique homepage and monographs links, local and external, return HTTP 200. Playwright’s request hosts are only 127.0.0.1:8773. The server log’s one 404 during that session is GET /favicon.ico.
gitleaks detect --log-opts e2edc607..2ef9921b scanned 1 commit, reported no leaks, and wrote 0 findings.
Adds
monographs/index.htmlso https://foundation-0.github.io/gravity/monographs/ serves a page, and links it from the homepage.What changes
monographs/index.html(new): lists all 15 files inmonographs/SHA256SUMS, grouped as the four monograph PDFs, their LaTeX sources and the seven figures. Each row has the title, a relative link, size and SHA-256. Styling reuses the homepage CSS variables and the light/dark theme setting.index.html: a06 // Monographsnav link and aRead the Monographsbutton, both pointing atmonographs/.monographs/SHA256SUMSstays as it is.Claim labels
The page carries the same status notice as the PDFs: every result in the monographs is an unreproduced gem-nexus / Carbon claim, pending independent reproduction. Each row is badged
Pending reproduction, and each monograph row names its claims inCLAIMS.md: C-01 to C-11, C-12 to C-17, C-18 to C-20, and C-21 and C-22 (tested against the Wave 6 claim C-19). The Wave 6 row names M-01 to M-05 as the methods in Section 4 of that monograph, sinceCLAIMS.mdhas no M IDs andMETHODS_AND_PLAYBOOK.mduses those IDs for a different list.Base
Branched from #16's head
f5a5fb57, which is now on main through3605d72b. Against main3605d72bthe merge tree is clean,29f622acf52db3a954c5a3d9bb18957233a2d431at head2ef9921b, and the PR diff is these two files only.Checks run on the merge tree (served locally, headless Chrome, light and dark theme)
/monographs/.monographs/SHA256SUMSexactly, andsha256sum -cpasses 15/15./favicon.ico, which main has too.Side note for #15: the root
SHA256SUMSon main fails 11 of 36 entries today. This PR leaves that file alone.