Skip to content

Spinner tips: 14 shipped tips name commands, settings keys and gates v8 no longer has; spinner-tips skips on a default install and misreads scoped counts #2823

Open

Description

@Luo0oo

1. Fourteen tips in settings.enhancements.json (183 tips) state things that are not true of v8.761.0.

Kind Tip What v8 has
Wrong command "Use bun Inference.ts fast|standard|smart for AI inference" Inference.ts takes --level <low|medium|high|max> (LIFEOS/TOOLS/Inference.ts:31); the old names fail
Missing settings keys "The counts section in settings.json tracks skills, signals, files, and sessions." hooks/handlers/UpdateCounts.ts:14: "The settings.json.counts field is dead."
"v5.1: contextFiles is empty. …" no contextFiles key
"principal in settings.json stores your name, timezone, and voice clone." no voice-clone field: the principal mirror carries name, pronunciation and timezone (hooks/lib/identity.ts:321-326)
Retired Algorithm terms "The Quality Gate checks count, category diversity, testability, anti-criteria, and capabilities." no gate in LIFEOS/ALGORITHM/ checks count, category diversity or capabilities; the ISA format dropped count floors, and another shipped tip says so
"User-story validation runs through the Interceptor skill." / "Gate 4 (browser-based QA validation) runs via the Interceptor skill." no user-story validation or Gate 4 in the Algorithm or the Interceptor skill
Four "capability selection" tips: "Capability selection consults the skill listing…", "Selecting a capability creates a binding commitment…", "Verification checks every ISC criterion AND confirms every selected capability…", "The capability audit's ISC Improvement step…" no capability selection or capability audit in LIFEOS/ALGORITHM/ (two agent files, agents/Opus.md and agents/Astra.md, still mention "the capability selection")
Stale numbers "The Fabric skill runs 235 prompt patterns…" skills/Fabric/Patterns has 274 pattern directories with a system.md
"Cortex v8.3.0 (the memory system)…" ARCHITECTURE_SUMMARY.md: Cortex (Memory) v8.4.0
"/review-pr runs comprehensive PR review using 7 specialized analysis agents." not part of the payload; the pr-review-toolkit plugin, version 1.0.1, ships 6 agents

Two more tips are true but age badly: "52 public skills, 212 intents. Type / to see them all." (neither number matches the payload), and the history note on the Cato and Forge agents folding into Astra.

2. spinner-tips cannot cover the shipped tips. IntegrityCheck.ts checkSpinnerTips reads the tips from USER/CONFIG/settings.user.json and skips the whole check when that file has none ("public install"). The scaffolded overlay is {}. So the tips that are actually live, which the installer writes into settings.json as the installer-owned spinnerTipsOverride (MergeSettings.ts INSTALLER_OWNED_KEYS), are never checked until something puts tips into the overlay.

3. The count rule misreads scoped counts. The rule at IntegrityCheck.ts:1978 matches every "N intents|procedures|workflows" phrase and compares N with the total across all skills (:1966). A tip like "BeCreative has 7 intents" is therefore flagged although the payload has exactly 7 BeCreative intent files.

Suggested direction (yours to pick).

  • Drop numbers, versions and dates from tips, so they cannot go stale.
  • Point spinner-tips at the tips that are live: the installer-owned key, or both sources.
  • Have it check what a tip names, so that slash names, file names and settings keys resolve against the install.
  • Scope count claims to the skill they name, or leave them out.

Activity

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

No one assigned

    Labels

    No labels
    No labels

    Projects

    No projects

      Milestone

      No milestone

      Relationships

      None yet

      Development

      No branches or pull requests

      Issue actions