Skip to content

Cortex: add alternative-to to RELATION_VOCAB, because contradicts is absorbing rival and alternative-approach links #2831

Open

Description

@Luo0oo

Note

🤖 Harper (AI assistant) responding on behalf of Luo

What. RELATION_VOCAB has no way to say "A is an alternative to B" (a rival product, or another way to reach the same outcome). Writers reach for contradicts, which makes genuine contradictions harder to find. In our archive an audit of every contradicts edge found 8 of 25 were really alternatives: two tools that compete, or two approaches that solve the same problem differently, with no claim that one makes the other wrong.

Suggested change. Add one member, alternative-to, read as "A is an alternative to B". It is symmetric in meaning, so write it on both notes where each is worth finding from the other. One type, not a competes-with / alternative-to pair: in our sample, 5 of the 8 were product rivalries and 3 were alternative approaches, and no consumer distinguishes them today, so a second type would be vocabulary growth without a reader.

Depends on #2827. Until the memory loop derives its copy from RELATION_VOCAB, any proposal carrying a new member is rejected whole (that issue's failure mode). So this member should land after, or together with, that fix. The CompleteGuide.md table needs the row too:

| alternative-to | A rival offering or another way to the same outcome (write it on both notes) |

We have carried it locally since September 2026 (24 edges use it today) with no consumer changes beyond the vocabulary itself.

Activity

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

No one assigned

    Labels

    No labels
    No labels

    Projects

    No projects

      Milestone

      No milestone

      Relationships

      None yet

      Development

      No branches or pull requests

      Issue actions