Skip to content

Resume saved Claude conversations when the running model is absent from the picker #1239

Open

Description

@taras

Story

When I reconnect to a saved Claude conversation without requesting a model change, XMD should resume that same conversation with the model Claude reports, even if the model’s exact ID is absent from the picker.

Current gap

The reconnect check introduced by #1214 requires Claude’s reported model ID to appear verbatim in the selectable catalog. In #1200 the conversation reported claude-opus-5-5 and the picker offered opus. A later Problem Solver follow-up reproduced the refusal when Claude resumed the saved Fable conversation as claude-fable-5-2, while its picker offered fable and claude-fable-5-1. XMD refused before sending the follow-up in either case.

Contract

  • On an unchanged reconnect, verify the saved native conversation identity with the existing provider identity checks and preserve and report the backend-observed model. Catalog membership and alias matching are unnecessary for this path. Send no model-setting request or replacement-session request.
  • Use the existing provider catalog for the picker, fresh model selection, and explicit model changes. When a requested change needs model equivalence to be verified, require provider evidence for the model and context variant. Preserve the existing effort, context, permission, and identity guarantees.
  • Apply and verify an explicit model change before sending the prompt. A mismatched or unverifiable native identity, or an explicit selection that cannot be verified, refuses before prompting.

Acceptance

  • Exercise cold reconnect against the Claude adapter boundary with the saved native identity and a backend-reported model ID missing from the picker. Verify the prompt reaches the same conversation, the reported model is exact, and no model write or new session occurs. Cover both the Opus alias case and the Fable catalog mismatch.
  • Cover fresh selection, a verified explicit model change, an unverifiable explicit selection, and a different native identity.
  • Update the ACP client spec to match the reconnect contract.

Activity

  1. changed the title [-]Resume Claude conversations when the model is offered under an alias[/-] [+]Resume saved Claude conversations when the running model is absent from the picker[/+] on Nov 17, 2026
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

No one assigned

    Labels

    bugSomething isn't working

    Projects

    No projects

      Milestone

      No milestone

      Relationships

      None yet

      Development

      No branches or pull requests

      Issue actions