Repository navigation
Add Waves 1-7 monographs and figures from the 2026-11-13 vault drop - #17
Conversation
Add the Waves 1-7 monograph PDFs, LaTeX sources, and figure PDFs from the 13 November 2026 vault drop under monographs/, with a SHA256SUMS manifest. Signed-off-by: Orda <342776047+orda-aska@users.noreply.github.com>
ahrazzle
left a comment
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Request changes. The drop is the 16 files the author named, the hashes check, and each TeX file builds to the committed PDF. The monograph sources still present those claims as proved and verified, and they cite a path and SHA-256 prefixes that are absent from this head. The unreproduced gem-nexus label is only in the PR body. There are no earlier reviews, no conversation comments, and no inline threads.
git diff --name-status 68954f8b367e5e4654dadbbee6da322acf1ed678...8ed0c08958cb4d02842f1d8f5ef392b6c895f108 is 16 lines, all A, all under monographs/: SHA256SUMS, 4 PDFs, 4 TeX files, and 7 figure PDFs. git diff --stat is 16 files changed, 802 insertions(+). GitHub reports the same counts (changed_files: 16, additions: 802, deletions: 0). The single commit’s parent is 68954f8b367e5e4654dadbbee6da322acf1ed678.
From the repo root, sha256sum -c monographs/SHA256SUMS exits 1: sha256sum: WARNING: 15 listed files could not be read, then 15 FAILED open or read lines. The manifest lists bare filenames. From monographs/, sha256sum -c SHA256SUMS prints 15 OK lines for every name in that file. Those 15 digests are the same 15 digests in the PR table. monographs/SHA256SUMS is the 16th file.
Each .tex was copied to /tmp/mono-build with its figures and run twice with pdflatex -interaction=nonstopmode -halt-on-error (TeX Live 2023, pdfTeX 1.40.25). All four second passes exit 0. pdfinfo page counts match the committed PDFs: quantum monograph 8, forces monograph 5, wave 6 5, wave 7 4. pdftotext -layout normalized text is identical for wave 6 and wave 7. The other two differ only in pdfTeX 1.40.24 versus 1.40.25 extraction (token ratios 0.999652 and 0.998405): a superscript 2 split into its own token, and a space in ( C-14). Titles, authors, page size, and PDF 1.5 match. The rebuilt files are newer (CreationDate Fri Nov 13 2026, Producer pdfTeX-1.40.25) and are not byte-identical.
Every \includegraphics path exists beside the source: fig1–fig3 in the quantum monograph, fig4 and fig5 in the forces monograph, fig6 in wave 6, fig7 in wave 7. No \input or \include. The second-pass logs have no missing-file errors.
pdfinfo opens all 11 PDFs, Encrypted: no. Figure PDFs are Matplotlib 3.10.1, one page each, created Wed Nov 11 2026. Monograph authors are the public Foundation-0 / Gemini / orda-aska attribution already in the sources. A byte scan of the PDFs and pdftotext found no email, no /Users or /home path, no file://, and no key material. PTEX.FileName values are relative ./<figure>.pdf. gitleaks detect --no-git --source monographs and gitleaks detect on 68954f8b..8ed0c08 both report no leaks found (0 findings). An rg pass for key and token patterns in the TeX hits only the word “tokens” in monographs/wave6_convergence_and_methods_monograph.tex:153.
The PR table is those 15 files. The omitted-file table is these 13, and none of them are in the diff: CHANGELOG.md, CLAIMS.md, README.md, SHA256SUMS, formal/GravityClaims.lean, formal/Wave5StochasticForces.lean, formal/Wave6Convergence.lean, formal/Wave7ThresholdAudit.lean, formal/verify_exact_rational_proofs.py, index.html, results/wave4_unified_certificates.json, verify_all.py, wave5_unified_forces_stochastic_qm.py. SHA-256 of each path on this tree matches the PR’s main column. Line counts match where the body gives them (Lean 54 / 67 / 100 / 102, verify_exact_rational_proofs.py 88, verify_all.py 395). results/wave4_unified_certificates.json has the key sha_26_canonical. wave5_unified_forces_stochastic_qm.py:1 is """ with a trailing space. CHANGELOG.md:51 repeats a trailing fragment on the Waves 1–2 line. CLAIMS.md says “fermionic radiation factor”. Drive file 11EuU7Nc1sxopuLKNoKjJ2YukysSU1Czp is named 2026-11-13_gravity-waves1-12-and-project-asma-bridge.zip and is 2198536 bytes, the same size as the body. The public download URL returns a Google sign-in page, so this review did not recompute the zip digest or the inner drop hashes.
rg of monographs/*.tex finds neither unreproduced nor gem-nexus. The claim rows are tagged PROVEN / VERIFIED (forces monograph lines 94–99, quantum monograph lines 96–104, wave 7 line 52). monographs/unified_forces_and_stochastic_quantum_monograph.tex:83 cites formal/wave5_exact_rational_proofs.py, which is not in the tree; the file on this head is formal/verify_exact_rational_proofs.py. SHA-256 prefixes in the four sources (040a757f, 99c24407, 1184c304, 2d585551, 923d85f1, f93c9da8, 6b905845, 973d6f1d, including the full 6b905845aaca043a… digest at wave 6 line 79) match no file hash on this head. CLAIMS.md, which this PR leaves in place, tags the same ids as computed, empirical, conjecture, known-literature, or PROVEN (ARITHMETIC-LEMMA) only. README.md states the Lean files check integer and rational identities and do not prove physical force laws, Bell’s theorem, or weak-equivalence bounds.
Pages source is main at / (gh api repos/Foundation-0/gravity/pages, build_type: legacy). The live site already returns 200 for /gravity/README.md, /gravity/SHA256SUMS, and /gravity/verify_all.py. /gravity/monographs/SHA256SUMS is 404 on the current build, whose commit is 68954f8b. A merge rebuilds pages-build-deployment and will serve monographs/ at https://foundation-0.github.io/gravity/monographs/. README.md, index.html, CLAIMS.md, and CHANGELOG.md do not link monographs/. There is no CITATION.cff, _config.yml, .nojekyll, or .github/ on this tree. The head has 0 check runs. Three Actions workflow objects still exist in the API, and GET contents/.github/workflows?ref=68954f8 is 404, so they are not in this merge.
Fixes
- In all four
monographs/*.texfiles, put an explicit unreproduced gem-nexus / Carbon label on the claim ledgers and on the lines that say the results are verified or certified. Rebuild the four PDFs, then updatemonographs/SHA256SUMSand the PR hash table so Pages serves the labelled text. - Remove or retarget citations that do not exist on this head:
formal/wave5_exact_rational_proofs.pyatmonographs/unified_forces_and_stochastic_quantum_monograph.tex:83, and the SHA-256 prefixes040a757f,99c24407,1184c304,2d585551,923d85f1,f93c9da8,6b905845, and973d6f1d. - Retag the monograph claim rows to the statuses
CLAIMS.mdalready uses on this branch, and keep Lean citations insidePROVEN (ARITHMETIC-LEMMA)(C-12 isCOMPUTED (KNOWN-FRAMEWORK) / CONJECTURE, C-16 isKNOWN-LITERATURE-VALUE, C-19 isCONJECTURE / PHENOMENOLOGICAL-ANSATZ).
…CLAIMS.md Addresses review 5887065374 on #17: - add an unreproduced gem-nexus / Carbon label and status notice to all four monographs, on the claim ledgers and on each verified or certified line - retag every claim row to the CLAIMS.md status; Lean citations appear only as PROVEN (ARITHMETIC-LEMMA) - retarget formal/wave5_exact_rational_proofs.py to formal/verify_exact_rational_proofs.py and replace stale SHA-256 prefixes with raw file digests of the matching files on main at 68954f8 - rebuild the four PDFs (pdfTeX 1.40.29, TeX Live 2026, SOURCE_DATE_EPOCH=1794528000) and update monographs/SHA256SUMS Signed-off-by: Orda <342776047+orda-aska@users.noreply.github.com>
|
Re review 5887065374: the fixes are in bd773d1 (parent 8ed0c08).
|
ahrazzle
left a comment
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Approve. Commit bd773d1f (parent 8ed0c08958cb4d02842f1d8f5ef392b6c895f108) answers review 5887065374 the way smith's comment 6846110461 describes. The three fixes are in the four monographs, the hashes check, and a pdfTeX 1.40.29 rebuild is byte-identical to the committed PDFs.
git diff --stat 8ed0c089..bd773d1f is 9 files changed, 119 insertions(+), 57 deletions(-). git diff --name-status is nine M lines, all under monographs/: SHA256SUMS, the four TeX sources, and the four monograph PDFs. The seven figure blobs are the same object ids as on 8ed0c089. The commit message ends with Signed-off-by: Orda <342776047+orda-aska@users.noreply.github.com>. gitleaks detect --source . --log-opts='8ed0c089..bd773d1f' scanned 1 commit and reported no leaks found (0 findings).
cd monographs && sha256sum -c SHA256SUMS prints OK for all 15 names. Those digests are the middle column of the updated PR table, including the new monograph PDF and TeX hashes. The seven figure hashes are unchanged from the zip column.
Each TeX file defines \statusnotice and calls it immediately after the title block. The notice names the 2026-11-13 gem-nexus / Carbon drop, says every result is an unreproduced claim, and limits Lean to PROVEN (ARITHMETIC-LEMMA). The claim ledgers carry \unrepro, which expands to [unreproduced gem-nexus / Carbon claim]: quantum caption and the sentence before Table ledger, forces line 98 and the wave-5 caption, wave 6 line 110, and the wave 7 verdict box C-21, C-22: EMPIRICAL-FIT. pdftotext -layout shows that bracketed label in all four PDFs (wave 7 verdict on its page-1 line, plus the C-22 lemma line). A search for PROVEN, VERIFIED, certified, and verified leaves PROVEN only next to ARITHMETIC-LEMMA, and verified/certified only inside the status notice that already says those lines are unreproduced. The old prefixes 040a757f, 99c24407, 1184c304, 2d585551, 923d85f1, f93c9da8, 6b905845, and 973d6f1d, and the path formal/wave5_exact_rational_proofs.py, are absent.
pdfinfo on the committed monographs: Producer pdfTeX-1.40.29, CreationDate Fri Nov 13 00:00:00 2026 UTC (date -u -d @1794528000 is that instant), pages 6 (forces), 8 (quantum), 5 (wave 6), 5 (wave 7). TeX Live 2026 from the 2026-11-13 net installer gives pdfTeX 3.141592653-2.6-1.40.29. Two pdflatex -interaction=nonstopmode -halt-on-error passes with SOURCE_DATE_EPOCH=1794528000 and FORCE_SOURCE_DATE=1 exited 0, and cmp -s reported IDENTICAL for all four monograph PDFs.
The wave-5 ledger now cites formal/verify_exact_rational_proofs.py with d0acfe8e.... Raw sha256sum of each mapped file on this tree (those paths are unchanged from 68954f8) matches the PR body: results/certificates.json dbd75930…, results/wave3_empirical_certificates.json a44b0337…, results/wave4_unified_certificates.json 824d1a5d…, results/exact_rational_proof_certificates.json 3ddae446…, wave5_unified_forces_stochastic_qm.py effc8ef2…, formal/verify_exact_rational_proofs.py d0acfe8e…, results/wave6_convergence_certificates.json 3fac90c8… (the full digest is in the wave 6 caption), and results/wave7_group_cluster_certificates.json 6e6297b1…c2d741. 040a757f is the sha256_canonical value inside results/certificates.json, and 2d585551 is the sha256_canonical value inside results/exact_rational_proof_certificates.json. The 923d85f1 slot is the wave-5 script: the ledger sentence names wave5_unified_forces_stochastic_qm.py, and effc8ef2 is that file. It is not results/wave5_forces_stochastic_certificates.json (raw 26fe25f6…, sha256_canonical 5abd85ab…). M-05 lists that same script digest beside the results/ JSON digests, and the sentence says both certificate files and raw file digests.
Ledger tags match CLAIMS.md: C-01 and C-02 COMPUTED (KNOWN-FRAMEWORK) with a Lean lemma line; C-03 COMPUTED (KNOWN-FRAMEWORK) and no Lean line (CLAIMS.md says none); C-04 COMPUTED (KNOWN-FRAMEWORK, MODEL-DEPENDENT) with a lemma; C-05 COMPUTED (KNOWN-FRAMEWORK) / CONJECTURE; C-06 COMPUTED (TOY-MODEL); C-07 COMPUTED (KNOWN-FRAMEWORK); C-08 EMPIRICAL-FIT (KNOWN-FRAMEWORK); C-09 COMPUTED (MODEL-FAMILY-SCAN) with a lemma; C-10 COMPUTED (BVP-SOLVER); C-11 COMPUTED (KNOWN-FRAMEWORK); C-12 COMPUTED (KNOWN-FRAMEWORK) / CONJECTURE with a lemma; C-13 COMPUTED (KNOWN-FRAMEWORK) / CONJECTURE and no lemma; C-14 COMPUTED (MASS-RATIO ARITHMETIC) with a lemma; C-15 COMPUTED (KNOWN-FRAMEWORK); C-16 KNOWN-LITERATURE-VALUE with a lemma; C-17 COMPUTED (KNOWN-FRAMEWORK). Wave 6 line 110 is C-18 COMPUTED (KNOWN-FRAMEWORK) / CONJECTURE, C-19 CONJECTURE / PHENOMENOLOGICAL-ANSATZ, C-20 COMPUTED (ALGEBRAIC-IDENTITY) / CONJECTURE, with Lean limited to PROVEN (ARITHMETIC-LEMMA). The wave 7 verdict is C-21, C-22: EMPIRICAL-FIT.
This pull request adds the Waves 1-7 monograph PDFs, their LaTeX sources, and the seven figure PDFs from the 13 November 2026 vault drop. The files are placed under
monographs/, matching the zip directorygravity_monographs/.gem-nexus presents this drop as the Waves 1-12 gravity record, alongside the solvers and Lean modules already on
main. That presentation is an unreproduced Carbon claim, pending independent review.Provenance
2026-11-13_gravity-waves1-12-and-project-asma-bridge.zip(2,198,536 bytes)54ed879d5dd8fb87a1c327c5cf7057ff6537724f796aefb5fe86b4ab861fb7admainat68954f8b367e5e4654dadbbee6da322acf1ed678The zip SHA-256 and all 60 inner paths match the bundled
SHA256SUMS. The largest PDF is 538,267 bytes (unified_quantum_condensate_gravity_monograph.pdf). The repository has no Git LFS attributes.Files added
monographs/fig1_rar_and_scale_flow.pdf0037118b5b13ae6d847d150d1c39bdf6f9e1b4ead4735b72c170d27cf99a7b6bmonographs/fig2_nogo_theorems.pdfbd0fabe3406227135cff22a61004bac4668dda290c9abb05550ba981c38cb65emonographs/fig3_bogoliubov_unification.pdf5dfcd466290ffa2fff6c4f95595848f2cc715e17b1c48baa59e1a58678c506b1monographs/fig4_unified_force_phases.pdf2d9f5f06b3ae79539caa36a455da5b9ab81b85226fba2bf9075ff4d1ff2baf8emonographs/fig5_stochastic_quantum_emergence.pdf72b63c59a98f9e8ca250caf50a8b52d24cad36f53bd53f34600acc4b140adc3dmonographs/fig6_convergence_unification.pdf1c5b640d82c27a5deae095f70374e960fca75d62c9e3d52ad66ebaa6fde6879amonographs/fig7_group_cluster_threshold_audit.pdf51563fd9eb34cd4a1118042299c9d70f03b8d0ccaf040d0d46db25b23ecc744bmonographs/unified_forces_and_stochastic_quantum_monograph.pdff4740a7816a8b085bf59b0cc97784dce0c96ce86ea247cc1b2e07965eeb26668cc993add96e15de062078eedd504f74b14169f4fc3e14b1834ecfaf9c030500dmonographs/unified_forces_and_stochastic_quantum_monograph.texb614db58068da3086806fe413c6a9f7b6feb43e8e3609b67e2eade33d2bd8a6e658c19985852136b2596951129342dbc0cd6b206f49ac707ed66d6e989cb1c46monographs/unified_quantum_condensate_gravity_monograph.pdf1a087db2c0166eac653284a8902cd3b1c55122f8079ebe0dc21503008a7e7950b6a39ace006250a2e4292190b55cd339f13629289319794c758c4163956119c0monographs/unified_quantum_condensate_gravity_monograph.tex85d431bb946e9a4dcb49a13697ef4944ec6bbb2f04c5f736969927f51c37ccfdfd314c23541d733fd2e135701e3e310b31dd316cbf60461d86df7aee07a42952monographs/wave6_convergence_and_methods_monograph.pdf0abefc3ada9677e6c5714fd7ac1b29d886ec21ee2e01134197b2c00d4e24d03450a919afa61dde4b3b25932f1a5852f9571f094a2c640b4569b8d9dfb532861amonographs/wave6_convergence_and_methods_monograph.texb180c80cd4dd2fff90222faa95ee0b55be258a12bb3a986ec18590786710f96f7d4dc1001abbb44a9f0187851851fd0a66d0a517f38ee89a6c1f0ebfcb27c055monographs/wave7_group_cluster_roton_threshold_audit.pdfaba92bf9803125c3921076c64e30cc6b3162655b0f492ec601fd067e188a636de13056d4cc5c946261dc65c8acd558b399f261250abd2a9e850851dfde88a19amonographs/wave7_group_cluster_roton_threshold_audit.texfb127ea38bda38018843b1df3f374f90180d7e9220f77b8c17b079f22598bc8da1b61b14483c9e7388996c1f1a78dd8f4c78bed37640f5f3756faa26e239d55bmonographs/SHA256SUMSlists the 15 hashes in the middle column. Runsha256sum -c SHA256SUMSfrom insidemonographs/, since the manifest uses bare filenames.Changes after review 5887065374
The four TeX sources and their PDFs on this head now differ from the zip. The seven figure PDFs are unchanged. The zip hashes in the table above give the provenance of the original files.
[unreproduced gem-nexus / Carbon claim]label on its claim ledger and on every line that calls a result verified, certified, proven or machine-checked. Those words were replaced in the ledgers and captions with "reported".formal/wave5_exact_rational_proofs.pyis nowformal/verify_exact_rational_proofs.py. The SHA-256 prefixes that matched no file now point at the raw file digest of the matching file onmainat68954f8:040a757fresults/certificates.jsondbd759302d4f7666f0e6505d8af3ad1b690f1e8283680b0dca9c31492151528e99c24407results/wave3_empirical_certificates.jsona44b03375f26452e66aac5324199e41aeb77092c668dbc2adf0342caccb32a7c1184c304results/wave4_unified_certificates.json824d1a5d68f16a2383d6afd3397776d3f3ae99361595379eb827fa71d69321ea2d585551results/exact_rational_proof_certificates.json3ddae446816d764f94ba1d546317881cfe4036ce329da73b6894c27960914a9e923d85f1wave5_unified_forces_stochastic_qm.pyeffc8ef25d4489d9cf2d6ea0c0af78d7707fb2c246038f191c8cda22e2a8762df93c9da8formal/verify_exact_rational_proofs.pyd0acfe8ea3ab801f5538999979c3e4f69545b1734b02a998451d4263f69b3ce66b905845results/wave6_convergence_certificates.json3fac90c824cb0d5a30687230796086f7e10e3f151eb0047279b88e3aef525756973d6f1dresults/wave7_group_cluster_certificates.json6e6297b1654a89a0a204616de83106ffc1392679b13ce981ec114570f2c2d741040a757fand2d585551are thesha256_canonicalpayload values recorded inside the first and fourth files. The TeX now cites raw file digests so each one checks withsha256sum. The rootSHA256SUMSonmainis still the older 36-file manifest, so these digests were computed from the files themselves.CLAIMS.mdstatus. Rows with a Lean lemma add "Lean lemma: PROVEN (ARITHMETIC-LEMMA)". In the rows and in the running text, Lean is cited only as PROVEN (ARITHMETIC-LEMMA) for its integer or rational goals. C-12 isCOMPUTED (KNOWN-FRAMEWORK) / CONJECTURE, C-16 isKNOWN-LITERATURE-VALUE, and C-19 isCONJECTURE / PHENOMENOLOGICAL-ANSATZ. Wave 6 gains a status line for C-18 to C-20, and the wave 7 verdict box is tagged C-21 and C-22EMPIRICAL-FIT.The PDFs were rebuilt with pdfTeX 1.40.29 (TeX Live 2026), two passes each, with
SOURCE_DATE_EPOCH=1794528000andFORCE_SOURCE_DATE=1, so a rebuild with the same TeX Live gives byte-identical files. Page counts are now 6 (forces), 8 (quantum), 5 (wave 6) and 5 (wave 7); the status notice adds a page to two of them.Merging
Pages builds from
mainat/, so merging this PR publishesmonographs/athttps://foundation-0.github.io/gravity/monographs/. The merge waits for the owner's go and then goes to grk-ship.Drop files already on
mainOf the 38 files under the drop's
gravity/directory, 25 are byte-identical tomain. The other 13 already exist onmainand differ from the zip, so this PR leaves them as they stand.mainSHA-256CHANGELOG.md15bce514d05dcc3d52530931a36e02167a380144ac0628ab665340473cae0c9379133ad39cfc16b44707d174e35044c4e630f6d85c3a06dd0ba4f728c99bf88emainrepeats a trailing fragment on that line.CLAIMS.mdbbae4ed5f8da9582c75f2d6b198cdb5425ccf4c9c626fa97b32e8410aecb490f223059cc0b79fbc1dfe4c2ab801c2610ee898316e66409084f059a9b1aac1a23main.README.md7ef0ccad4d71620b53c85ff93f2afd5e36695e63ae8befeff91159706624b985b72f86c977c4b2052d70f4a82b4980db947f6c573e7bfae7e288d561c38b91aemainnext to theCHANGELOG.mdbullet.SHA256SUMS30ac4ed669fcaf6636b3b22558e6c8cf6ab93cb2a16b06e49c52c2f3bc6425dcc5bc024672af240187655c0986571082a668099b75b981f4fa3ba3737b1ab76dindex.htmland the drop hashes.mainstill carries the 36-file manifest fromd144448.formal/GravityClaims.leandb6e4a202d357b5bd175b20b971b3a79e3b34a573382e2f0e5ed4341d0507562c2e635f3af901aef8b51b529f46d2c16742c06c597a543e8cf518f4eb636f70emain54 lines.formal/Wave5StochasticForces.leana097c2ea83cf1ad0788d8969427737c6e5b1d2250d6c1f3f529178e39903eeda8702c37822bcc1178d5d5cade50d59929f8550a61a45cb38ebcc3c5e1d48b9f9main67 lines.formal/Wave6Convergence.leanfd52c8d997ccf9873cfd020f19f62b27dbfbdecda0234075ddd571193e0a93854474b263b026d97089dcd8cc154b4ec5964212554901e66a63b16f88094a106dmain100 lines.formal/Wave7ThresholdAudit.lean41cd166341b517f3ab316ad5987cd9c74e5a2d443d763d948cde869d285a0672f8b168944f4364fe6eb2b1af64695b224e5dd8f5ba8f086168b08fcc2bce3fd6main102 lines.formal/verify_exact_rational_proofs.py606431af2e1366cff43a658c65080f146789fe6e7159f317648cc621f7a8cb28d0acfe8ea3ab801f5538999979c3e4f69545b1734b02a998451d4263f69b3ce6main88 lines.index.html27bc65e4d2029086115da5782457cc8d4488075208faa241edf056c21f7545d47d6475634a4ec70e36a5ccbb9b9caac26d038ea1c6a94e909f10eb9de858c8d6</html>tag.mainis the later Pages head at68954f8.results/wave4_unified_certificates.json7bb2326b36aab2c09c542a112317e4afccd0ffee2f74cdd6a8cc2a65b230255e824d1a5d68f16a2383d6afd3397776d3f3ae99361595379eb827fa71d69321easha256_canonical;mainkeysha_26_canonical. The zip bytes match open #15.verify_all.py1e907f6af0b1dcc633feec478aebd4997e52f048f6d3ba99974f6c03a707dac149bd79489023aed0f6d1b325734012a6b6e0bf4b0b20755e83f20e7fd332583cmain395 lines.wave5_unified_forces_stochastic_qm.py290a9bbb1ddd8140e7e27c25a46ebf30012cf1c4c796e0d354f95a0a9f0ca327effc8ef25d4489d9cf2d6ea0c0af78d7707fb2c246038f191c8cda22e2a8762dmain.