Repository navigation
Closed as not planned
0 / 30 of 3 issues completedClosed as not planned
0 / 30 of 3 issues completed
Copy link
Labels
claude-triagedIssue has been triaged by the Claude Code triage routine. Remove to re-triage.Issue has been triaged by the Claude Code triage routine. Remove to re-triage.enhancementNew feature or requestNew feature or requestmember-toolsAll member tools - profiles, dashboards, content management, working groups, eventsAll member tools - profiles, dashboards, content management, working groups, eventswebsiteAny issues related to the websiteAny issues related to the website
Description
Summary
Track the work required for a person to keep their identity, profile, reputation, and appropriate personal access across email and employer changes while keeping company authorization strictly organization-scoped.
This began as one proposal, but it contains independent identity, affiliation, billing, and membership-product decisions. Those tracks now have separate owners and acceptance criteria.
Non-negotiable boundaries
- A person identity links verified credentials and person-owned state; it is not an organization entitlement source.
- An affiliation records employment/consulting history; it never grants access.
- Organization memberships, seats, roles, and employer-paid capabilities remain scoped to the selected organization.
- Personal subscriptions grant only their defined person-level capabilities.
- Aggregated person views retain source provenance and respect cross-surface privacy.
- A durable person record remains subject to deletion/anonymization and retention policy.
Workstreams
- Person identity and portable state: profiles, emails, points, and recovery #3590 — Person identity and portable state: profiles, verified credentials, points/reputation, safe merge/split, and privacy-aware MemberContext
- Affiliations and job-transition UX without authorization coupling #6819 — Affiliations and job-transition UX: current/historical employer relationships, visibility, and departure experience without authorization coupling
- Personal subscription continuity across employer and credential changes #6818 — Personal subscription continuity: persistent personal workspace and capability resolution across employer changes
Deferred product decisions
These should be evaluated independently after the foundations above; they do not belong in the identity schema:
- Free alumni/community offering and its capabilities
- Whether job loss defaults to free community access, a paid offer, or both
- A student tier and its verification method
Recommended delivery order
- Finish Person identity and portable state: profiles, emails, points, and recovery #3590's ownership model and verified personal recovery path.
- Establish explicit capability resolution for personal versus selected-organization access.
- Add affiliation history and job-transition UX against those stable boundaries.
- Test alumni/student offerings as product changes, not identity prerequisites.
Done state
- A person can change verified credentials or employers without losing person-owned profile/reputation state.
- Employer departure removes employer authorization immediately.
- A verified personal sign-in remains usable when available.
- Personal subscription access survives employer changes without leaking access between organizations.
- Current and former affiliations are represented with explicit visibility and no authorization semantics.
Supersedes the original combined A→E discussion scope. The linked issues are the implementation authorities.
Metadata
Metadata
Assignees
Labels
claude-triagedIssue has been triaged by the Claude Code triage routine. Remove to re-triage.Issue has been triaged by the Claude Code triage routine. Remove to re-triage.enhancementNew feature or requestNew feature or requestmember-toolsAll member tools - profiles, dashboards, content management, working groups, eventsAll member tools - profiles, dashboards, content management, working groups, eventswebsiteAny issues related to the websiteAny issues related to the website
Activity
bokelley commentedon Aug 24, 2026
Triage
Classification: Discussion / proposal
Bucket(s): member-tools, website
Status: ready-for-human
What the experts said:
identity_idrather than anyworkos_user_idthat ever linked to it; a paid student verifier rather than.edu-alone).My take: Steps A/B (finish migration
460_identities.sql, email ownership) are already the #3590 charter and shouldn't fork off. Steps C/D (time-bound Affiliation, portable reputation, person-level billing/tiers) are a real successor epic — but the three open product questions need answers before columns land.@bokelley, your call — how do you want to scope this against #3590?
Option A — fold identity work into #3590, keep #6814 for the additive scope:
Cleanest separation; #3590 stays the identity truth, #6814 becomes the billing/tier epic that depends on it. Keeps the existing #3590 security review,
no fuzzy auto-mergerule, and cross-surface privacy fence work intact.Option B — keep #6814 as-is, absorb #3590:
Simpler ownership if you'd rather drive one epic; costs #3590's sub-issue history and the security review already on that thread, and re-litigates the "no auto-merge / credentials bound to originating workos_user_id" contract that's already ratified there.
Also needs a ruling before any schema lands:
.edu+ 2-year time-box is right at AAO scale; security-reviewer says.edualone is spoofable (disposable-domain services, post-graduation carryover) and prefers SheerID storing only a token + expiry. Cost vs. robustness tradeoff.Triaged by Claude Code. Session: https://claude.ai/code/cse_01RJVoZC4khUTtCvSX1SZ2KR
Generated by Claude Code
[-]Person-centric profiles: retain members across jobs, multi-company, multi-email, individual/student tiers[/-][+]Umbrella: person continuity across jobs, affiliations, and personal membership[/+]bokelley commentedon Aug 24, 2026
Split completed:
Within #3590, portable reputation is #6816 and self-service verified recovery credentials are #6817. The first ownership/provenance contract is now in review in #6820.